By: Jeffrey Brower, Jonathan Espinoza, Dharani Krishnamoorthi, Kristen Seeba
Thursday, February 27, 2014
The Logos in the Photo
I think most people agree on this photo's intent: support the idea that women should receive "equal pay for equal work." Well, if we assume this to be the photo's intent, then I definitely see logos being used for this purpose. In total, I spot 2 instances of logos being used. Firstly, I believe this photo is promoting the logical fallacy that if we treat women and men in an equal fashion, then not only will women be happy but men will be too. This seems evidenced by a mirthful JFK and the laughing, happy women surrounding him. However as this cause and effect relationship is unlikely to truly make happiness last, it is indeed a logical fallacy. The second appeal to logic I note also seems to have a cause-effect relationship but it's not a logical fallacy. What is the most salient element in this photo other than the genuine mirth? To me, it's the fact that there sure are a lot of women in this room. After a head count, there are 14 women and 4 men in this room; 2 of these men are barely visible (I could only really see JFK and Lyndon B. Johnson's faces for sure). Furthermore, all these women want the Equal Pay Act to pass. However what if JFK had a change of heart and chose to just reject the bill there? These women, which could be representing the women in the U.S. workforce, could then choose to go on strike and not work at all. I see this as an ultimatum: give equal pay or kiss a third of the U.S. workforce goodbye (women at this time made this percentage of the workforce). This isn't a logical fallacy because if it were decided that women were not going to be treated equally in the workforce, then women very well could have stopped going to work.
Wednesday, February 26, 2014
Rhetorical Situation of "You Don't Own Me"
The 1960s were a time of gender-based discrimination and a hard fight for women's equality. The song "You Don't Own Me" is a powerful testament to this fight for equal rights. This song was written and released six months after the Equal Pay Act was enacted in 1963. This is important to note, considering that was a very important piece of legislation and received a large amount of media attention, yet there was no considerable immediate change in cultural standards, as noted in the song. Since the 1920s, women had expressed their desire to be treated equal to men, similar to the race discussion of the time. Parallels between racism and sexism can be found in the lyrics of this song, stressing importance for equality between all subsets of society. This song was released into a very thriving musical market, and still managed to perform very successfully. The song reached the number 2 spot on the Pop singles chart, beaten only by the Beatles song "I Want to Hold Your Hand." This mainstream popularity was a great success for the feminist movement, and this song was a very powerful addition to the equal rights movements in the 1960s.
-Jeff Brower
-Jeff Brower
The Rhetorical Situation Behind The Photo of the EPA’s Enactment
Before JFK signed the Equal Pay Act into law in June 10, 1963, without fear
of legal action being taken against them, American employers could pay their
female employees less than their male employees. As employers could do this, it
isn’t too surprising that in 1963, for the same work, women were in fact paid
almost 40% less than men in America. Although women made up a third of the U.S.
workforce at this time, they just weren’t viewed equal to men. However in the
1950’s and early 1960’s, change was occurring from the Civil Rights movement
and women desired change as well. Women wanted a change in the workplace as
they saw one made in the polling place by the 19th Amendment’s
passing in 1920. This amendment guaranteed the right to vote for all U.S.
citizens including women. In other nations, including Iron Curtain countries,
by 1963, laws were already passed to protect women from wage
discrimination.
- Jon Espinoza
Tuesday, February 25, 2014
JFK Equal Pay Act Audience
When evaluating rhetorical aspects of a photograph, or any
type of text, it is important to recognize the audience it is intended for, or
whom the photo is addressed to. The photo of President John F. Kennedy signing
the Equal Pay Act clearly was an important piece of our nation’s history and
some sort of documentation was essential.
This photograph seems to appeal to women, of all ages, in the United
States; when they see this photo, it reminds them that no longer will they
legally be hindered by discrimination in terms of salary. Women have the right to make as much money as
their male counterpart with the same job position. Women in the 1960’s would see the important
women that surround the President as he signs this act, and it would instill
the idea that they too can be influential and upstanding in society, and have
the same compensation as men in equal standing. This photo also appeals to
workingmen in the United States, showing that they may have more competition in
a work environment. From that point
forward, women would not just be sitting on the sidelines, accepting lower
pay for the same amount of work. Men could visually see that it was possible they wouldn't be their household breadwinners any longer.
-Kristen Seeba
-Kristen Seeba
Audience for Lesley Gore "You Don't Know Me"
The audience of this song was most likely women, but specifically young women. Lesley Gore started off her career as a singer with a #1 hit song at the age of 16 and she continued on with many more popular hits, including the song "You Don't Know Me" which emphasizes women's rights. So right from the beginning her pop music has an an audience of teens. In addition Gore's age of 17 (age at the time of release of song) gave her a leverage to influence her audience of young women because it allowed them to relate to her. Gore instantly gained this credibility of experiencing similar situations as the young women who were listening to her music. So ultimately young women could look to her for guidance and trust her. Because of this any message Gore expressed through her music would be accepted by a greater audience. The larger audience of this song is women in general regardless of age because the message being put forth by this song is that women are free and they can do as they please. The issue of women being restrained is an issue that a majority of women felt at that time so the song's audience was women in general
-Dharani Krishnamoorthi
-Dharani Krishnamoorthi
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)